This really is a case where we know very little, and what we think we know may have no foundation in the truth. There is just so much rubbish on the various tabloids and forums that it seems to me like a witch hunt. The parents really are suffering because of their perceived laxity in keeping an eye on their children, and I am sure that every screaming headline only reinforces their misery at their not having kept a closer watch. But I wouldn't dream of judging them. These things happen. Most of the time parents get away with it, and on the occasion they don't they have to live with the guilt for the rest of their lives. Even if Madeleine is found (which I hope and pray happens soon) they will still have to live with the memory of the days of misery she must have suffered while away from her family.
Everything that has been said here about the hired car is true. Why has the question not been raised in the tabloids as to where the car was between the abduction and the time the McCann's had it? We have been told by the more trustworthy newspapers that Robert Murat had to wait several hours for a hire-car around that time, because there are so few to be got. This suggests that a hire-car will be in constant use. And apart from the suggestion that this may be a set-up, there is also the chance of cross-contamination by a police force not as diligent as it could be. Even in a country like Britain where the police are careful about this, such occasions do occur.
On top of all this, it occurred to me yesterday, when I was trying to secrete my husband's birthday gift in a house with only three people in it, to wonder how on earth someone could hide the body of a four-year old child while being pursued by TV and other media journalists, interviewed by policemen and surrounded by well-wishing friends and relatives. To believe that the McCanns are guilty we must believe that many, if not all, of these friends and relatives are in on the crime. And with every person who knows about something, the chance of subterfuge lessens and the more likely it is that the secret will be outed.