Reminder to take writing advice with that grain of salt

[Kit]

It seems like we should be aware of the "rules" but know that it's ok to break them when it makes our writing better.  What do you think?

http://litreactor.com/columns/the-ten-worst-pieces-of-writing-advice-you-will-ever-hear-and-probably-already-have

Kit

[msgretagreen]

Thank you, Kit. I’m dwelling in a pit of conflicting feedback. Sometimes we just need to shut out all voices and “advice”.

[Kit]

I thought it was helpful to understand why these "rules" were established in the first place.  And ultimately, they're really more like guidelines. 

Good luck with your continued writing msgretagreen!

Kit

[heartsongjt]

Depends on whether or not the advice had a 'helpful' intent. By that, I mean, not everyone has the best of intention when giving another advice.

Even the best of intentions can come across 'mean spirited'...I think it all depends on how one shares their opinions [gives advice].

 I think,  there are times, one should refrain from expressing  an opinion /giving advice ,if they themselves would be offended, if those remarks were directed at them or their work.  Just my opinion.    Best of luck to everyone.  jt